Published by Cari Zancanelli under
on 6:30 AM
I didn't even know what to call this post at first. As I began pouring over blog posts and looked again at Intrinzen's website, and watched countless youtube videos, I felt empowered, excited, motivated, and...confused. The problem with being exploratory is that you learn information that ultimately conflicts with other information. Everything you know is constantly being challenged, re-hashed under new rules, looked at in new ways. Generally this is a good thing. Applying all this knowledge is difficult. What do I keep and what can be put aside?
Here's the problem: Enough time must be spent absorbing and learning about other methods and techniques so that you fully understand what the point is behind it. Then you have to try it out. Does it work for me? For the horse? Can I learn to do this by myself? Does it require a lot of equipment?
Does anything new negate everything else?
Is there some horse trainer/method out there that embodies all of these things?
1. Considers the horse a living being with thoughts and feelings. May sound silly, but this has become important to me. Must have buy-in from the horse or it won't work.
2. Their method is teachable to others. May seem obvious, but some people can't explain it and can't teach others. So it would be observational only if it can't be taught.
3. Must be easy to learn from reading about it, watching videos and blogs, online classes.
4. Must build the horse's strength, flexibility, athleticism to the end of being ridden.
5. Can be incorporated and used with other methods.
I'm looking for a system, a thought process, whatever you want to call it. I love clicker training, and yet it can become mechanical it seems. So I really like the idea of the clicker being used to teach the horse that it's okay to play. I like the mimicry where you show your horse the movement (need to understand that more), I like how easy it is to learn the clicker and how versatile. I like the idea of training without tack. I like Straightness Training as it brings back the reason for the exercises and how to use them to build a training plan to make your horse stronger.
I began watching Klaus Hempfling to learn more about mimicry and I'm frustrated again. He is using his body to communicate with the horse, but the videos are cryptic, the instruction vague. I have his book, Dancing with Horses I think it is. I have had it for years and only got so far.
I've read the HorseIdeology blog posts on Hempfling and she makes the point that it's very spiritually based and it's not a step-by-step thing. I was sitting here thinking about why that frustrates me. What do I really want with my horses? A relationship. The goal isn't to win medals or compete, the goal is to be closer to them and help us both be the best we can be. (That's not on my list of things I want in the training plan!!) "I want it NOW!", I think. And, as Pema Chodron always says, (paraphrasing) "this is where we get our speed, and speed destroys our purpose." Slow down, Cari. Slow down and enjoy the ride.
Published by Cari Zancanelli under
on 5:52 AM
Update. I've moved past Neil Davies. Although I really like the idea that he trains his horses with positive head rubs, he is stuck and doesn't have enough of an open mind to study other training methods. Here's what I've learned in the last few months....
I've been following a blog called "Horse Ideology" for awhile. It was originally posted for the owner to record her trainings, medical treatment and therapy for her new horse. In that sense, much of it was not of particular interest most of the time. However, she is very disciplined and does all her training on her own, through research much like I do. I admire her because of the discipline and organized approach she takes. I tend to find a new inspiring trainer, read their book and get all enthusiastic. I try out the basic parts of the method, and usually run up against something that really bothers me and throw most of it away or get sidetracked by life. This woman, however, keeps the parts she likes in use.
I mention this blog, though, because it has inspired me to become more disciplined in my training schedule. I would really like to implement the things I like into a plan and also learn new techniques and be more organized. I've written a lot about Empowered horses. I really like it and have learned there are people who have applied it in training. I've long complained about Spilker's (Empowered Horses) lack of structure. Sure, I'd love to work this way but I don't know what to do! This blog is the first instance where someone has found the bridge, the way to begin. I shouldn't say that she discovered the bridge herself, she found others that have.
If you have an older horse, and no constant supply of young prospects, you have to work with what you have. Somehow you have to change the conversation and prove to the horse that you will begin to listen to them. How?
There is also the question of time. Learning something new takes time, becoming proficient takes time, getting the horse finished takes time. One thing I never got to understand is how to build a horse's muscles. I know what a muscular horse looks like, but in dressage the specific exercises are used to accomplish this. How does one use the exercises and in which order? From this blog I've learned about straightness training, which is a good start. I'm working out how to put it all together and make training plans for each horse. The exercises are ones I either know or know of, and the next step is to learn to teach the horse how to do them with the clicker. I've found some videos on line but they are somewhat vague about the entire process.
Still, all of these new things and old things coming together are exciting. The clicker speeds things up immensely as the horse can be communicated to directly and accurately. This is so important - other methods of training are approximations of saying "no" over and over again.
It's like the game of "hot and cold", where someone goes looking for something and you say "hot" if they're near it and "cold" if they aren't. Most traditional horse training is like using the word "cold" exclusively, over and over - "nope, nope, nope!" Is what the horse mainly gets. Don't do that! What they need to know is what TO do.
I was using this method in Rifle quite a bit and then we moved, the horses were far away and my contact came down to grooming them once a month for an hour, and maybe a short ride. It was awful! But they had a nice pasture and lots of friends, so I didn't worry about their mental health. Once they got moved over here I began riding them more and at least seeing them more often, but my training plan has been non-existent. I have been afraid to use clicker training in front of other people, but my new-found connections support it whole-heartedly and I feel much more confident.
Now we are down to brass tacks, which means it's time to get to work. I'm writing a short training plan for each horse and as soon as I can I'm committing myself as much as I can. Maybe I could stop on the way home each morning? Or when I wake up until the days get short? That said, I'm still conflicted about the empowerment of the horse issue. Here's my take: if your training is fun, and makes the horse feel good, they will want to participate. If they are bored I'll know it by their behavior. In the meantime it's necessary for them to trust me enough to participate. The fact that they gather around me when I go into the pen says a lot, I think! My gut also tells me that their reaction when I go out to them is one of happiness to see me. I feel guilty for not being there enough. In that sense they seek having contact.
In my next post I'll include links to the new websites I've learned about and detail my training plan. To keep me honest...
So this is, as my husband likes to jokingly say, "A new beginning". Maybe not complete empowerment, but teaching based on positive reinforcement and joy. That makes me feel very good!
Published by Cari Zancanelli under
on 9:26 PM
There are things we can't explain. I have always fully accepted the mystery of life. Keeps things from getting boring, right? But more so it encompasses the spiritual part of life. We want to understand everything...to a point. If everything was fully understood the mystery would be gone and so would the magic.
My last post was about Herd and making a connection with Luna. Since I began working on this relationship with her I've also been seeing blog posts and things from other horse people, mainly trainers. They all like to down play the "love" part of having a horse, which is ironic when compared to dogs. People openly love their dogs, they tell others and write stories and make movies about it. It's so obvious that there is an emotional connection between many dogs and their owners. Have you ever seen a movie or read a story about a dog that sits by the grave of their owner if they die first?
According to popular tradition, horses apparently don't have this capacity. Even the more open bloggers and some trainers are reluctant to say that horses do things out of love. It is important to separate training principles from emotional connections, but once established, it's difficult to separate the two.
Just as in relationships we have with people are often those of connection and love, this doesn't mean they will do everything we ask of them. If there is mutual trust, then it's easy to ask things of the other person. As with animals, if there isn't trust in the relationship then there will be problems with the training.
How do you build trust? Consistency. Patience, calmness. As Neil Davies says, "never scare your horse". If you take nothing else from him I think that's a huge takeaway because much of "traditional" training involves purposely scaring horses. "Desensitization" is purposeful scaring of the animal until it accepts the thing it's afraid of, which is called "learned helplessness". I once was trying to get a yearling to accept a horse blanket and she was terrified. I kept holding it up to her back and she'd run in a circle, snorting and pawing at it, sweating. We were getting nowhere after a good 20 minutes of this. It wasn't working and both myself and the horse ended up frustrated. This was an "Ah Ha!" moment for me, a moment when I really saw that this method was not only NOT working, it was making things worse!
If you are the cause of fear, you are always holding the scary thing and forcing it on them you become the source of the fear. It's you demanding that they accept it, not that it happens to be in the environment and you're walking by.
Trust builds connection, spending time builds connection, taking time to groom or scratch or do whatever your horse enjoys doing builds connection. Even if you're a terrible rider, or you know nothing, or you think you're a bad horseperson, you can still have trust and connection. A lady I once gave lessons to really had a strong connection to her horse. I would do training rides on the horse and set boundaries and things that she wasn't doing as a rider, but that horse did not care how well it was being ridden. When the woman arrived at the barn I knew immediately because her horse would stop to watch her walk all the way from her car to the arena. He loved her.
I know that horses can and do love their people and vice versa. Not to acknowledge that is to ignore the beauty and richness of why we ride and why we love horses. Can I explain it? No. Do I think my horse does things for me because he or she loves me? Sometimes, yes. Do horses refuse to do things we ask and still love us? I think so. Do I do things because I love my horse? Yes, everything I do is for love. I can't tell you why I was born loving horses. There are many of us that feel the same and have always felt that way. It's immediate and so deep that it was never a question.
There is so much out there about training, and very little about the connection. I am just recently discovering those people who train with joy and positivism. I'm excited for the future for once!