A bit about clicker training
Published by Cari Zancanelli under clicker training, Clinton Anderson, natural horsemanship, Sea World on 3:30 PM
No, didn't fall off the edge of the earth! March was a tough month. After the loss of BJ we got more bad news (a friend's father committed suicide) and I lost all desire to do anything. Then we went to San Diego for a week which was at once wonderful and awful. Won't go in to the awful part... I had hoped to blog on the road and more negative issues made it impossible. So, that's my excuse and I'm sticking to it!
As someone who recently became enamoured with clicker training I must say that visiting Sea World was awesome! I haven't broached the subject here yet, but basically clicker training for horses is the same method that is used to train dolphins and other exotic animals. When training aquatic animals or even fish, one cannot use coercion, which I feel is often used to train horses. You simply cannot force a dolphin, killer whale, etc, to do something it doesn't want to do - it will just swim away. Even if contained in a pool, there is no way to get that animal to do anything you want using punishment. The only way is to use positive reinforcement training.
This type of method uses a sound (or lights or some other reinforcer) such as a whistle for dolphins or a clicker for dogs and horses to mark a wanted behavior. It basically says "yes, that's it!" The sound is followed by a reward. The reward reinforces the behavior - it causes the animal to want to do it more in order to get a reward.
If you are a believer in traditional horse training all this sounds very alien and against common training methods. I thought that way too, at first, but I have since changed my mind. About 2 years ago I attended a Clinton Anderson clinic. I was completely hooked on Clinton and his method. For the record, his method is basically traditional, as is any training under the header "natural horsemanship". The methods used, some more harsh or gentle than others, are all basically the same. Ask the horse to do something (say, move its hip over) and when it doesn't respond increase the pressure. If you use a finger to move the horse's hip you press harder. If you use a "stick" of some type, tap and then tap harder. And harder. According to Clinton, the "reward" is removing the pressure. In other words, you stop "tapping", pushing, prodding and whacking.
Clinton is VERY good at what he does. His timing is perfect and he can minimize the use of whacking by being very judicious with it. When you watch him it appears that he really isn't being so terrible because he does it fast and gets a response. When I went home from the clinic I immediately began to work with all my horses using things I had learned at the clinic (actually it was one of those mass marketing deals where you watch him train horses, not something I participated in with my own horse).
Two of my horses, Angel and Snickers, were 9 and 11 respectively when we bought them and they knew very little. I immediately began trying things out on them and will never forget the look on Angel's face when I whacked her really hard on the neck for the fourth time. I got NO response except a very hurt and surprised look from her. She never moved away from the pressure, instead she got angry at me. Let me say that I truly believe that if Clinton did the same exercise with my horse he could have gotten her to move over no problem - I know my faults.
I didn't like the tapping really hard part and although I tried my best I think my doubt crept in. I know Clinton's methods work because I can see him succeeding. I am also not critical of him because had I been in his shoes when I was young and had the chance to learn those things I would have done it and I would be giving clinics all over creation. He is teaching what he knows and he is really good at it. I still admire him, but I choose what I think is a better and easier way to train a horse.
Clicker training is better because you are communicating with your horse by saying "yes" and that is very powerful. Using the traditional method you are basically saying "no" - think about it... So all you are telling them is "no, NOT THAT!" It has the potential to create a lot of confusion. "If not that, then what should I do?" I imagine them saying. Yes, Clinton does give the animal a scratch and says "good boy" occasionally.
But is a scratch on the head a true reward? Is it enough to keep them wanting to do more?
When I tried clicker training for the first time it was miraculous to me. Things that I had tried and tried to train suddenly became very easy. For example, Snickers was very head shy when we got him. I had worked with him some to lower his head but the "reward" of letting go of the rope when he lowered his head didn't really entice him to want to do it. Older horses are always more difficult. So the first thing I did with the clicker was teach him to lower his head. It was wonderful! He wanted to do it more, and he followed me around after wanting more training!
Since then I have taught three foals all kinds of things, and worked with about ten other horses on various things that they have a problem with. My horse Bella, a mustang, is extremely head shy. I have worked diligently and extensively over the years to get her over this. It always takes weeks and lots of patience and in the end she tolerates it. Then, just when I think I've gotten her over it she explodes and I have to start over again. I still can't put the reins over her head. So I began using the clicker to get the reins over her head. In one 5 minute session she stopped throwing her head away from my hand (she can does this violently) and actually relaxed and let me bring the reins up to her ears. For the first time she lowered her head willingly and by herself while I lifted the reins near her ears. I will keep you posted on the progress of this. I also hope to use it to get her in the trailer...
Although it takes timing and patience just like traditional training does, using a clicker is generally a much easier to train. I also find it safer, calmer and the results come so much faster. The horse tends to remember the training, even if it was brief, because using this method activates the part of the brain called the "seeking circuit" which is a pleasure center. Certain types of activity activate this brain function and the memory of it stays there for a long time. It works similarly to the fear circuit, in which things that scare an animal stay in memory for a long time.
Using traditional training methods I would end up fighting with my horses, trying to be the tough one, showing them I was boss. I'm not saying I was good at it. I wasn't. I am good at clicker training and the results say it all. Snickers and Angel and actually all my horses have come so far in a short time without the rodeo. I don't feel bad for what I have to do, I enjoy it more. Now when I go out to the pasture to get a horse to train they all come running up to me, eager. I now train on a first come, first serve basis!
As someone who recently became enamoured with clicker training I must say that visiting Sea World was awesome! I haven't broached the subject here yet, but basically clicker training for horses is the same method that is used to train dolphins and other exotic animals. When training aquatic animals or even fish, one cannot use coercion, which I feel is often used to train horses. You simply cannot force a dolphin, killer whale, etc, to do something it doesn't want to do - it will just swim away. Even if contained in a pool, there is no way to get that animal to do anything you want using punishment. The only way is to use positive reinforcement training.
This type of method uses a sound (or lights or some other reinforcer) such as a whistle for dolphins or a clicker for dogs and horses to mark a wanted behavior. It basically says "yes, that's it!" The sound is followed by a reward. The reward reinforces the behavior - it causes the animal to want to do it more in order to get a reward.
If you are a believer in traditional horse training all this sounds very alien and against common training methods. I thought that way too, at first, but I have since changed my mind. About 2 years ago I attended a Clinton Anderson clinic. I was completely hooked on Clinton and his method. For the record, his method is basically traditional, as is any training under the header "natural horsemanship". The methods used, some more harsh or gentle than others, are all basically the same. Ask the horse to do something (say, move its hip over) and when it doesn't respond increase the pressure. If you use a finger to move the horse's hip you press harder. If you use a "stick" of some type, tap and then tap harder. And harder. According to Clinton, the "reward" is removing the pressure. In other words, you stop "tapping", pushing, prodding and whacking.
Clinton is VERY good at what he does. His timing is perfect and he can minimize the use of whacking by being very judicious with it. When you watch him it appears that he really isn't being so terrible because he does it fast and gets a response. When I went home from the clinic I immediately began to work with all my horses using things I had learned at the clinic (actually it was one of those mass marketing deals where you watch him train horses, not something I participated in with my own horse).
Two of my horses, Angel and Snickers, were 9 and 11 respectively when we bought them and they knew very little. I immediately began trying things out on them and will never forget the look on Angel's face when I whacked her really hard on the neck for the fourth time. I got NO response except a very hurt and surprised look from her. She never moved away from the pressure, instead she got angry at me. Let me say that I truly believe that if Clinton did the same exercise with my horse he could have gotten her to move over no problem - I know my faults.
I didn't like the tapping really hard part and although I tried my best I think my doubt crept in. I know Clinton's methods work because I can see him succeeding. I am also not critical of him because had I been in his shoes when I was young and had the chance to learn those things I would have done it and I would be giving clinics all over creation. He is teaching what he knows and he is really good at it. I still admire him, but I choose what I think is a better and easier way to train a horse.
Clicker training is better because you are communicating with your horse by saying "yes" and that is very powerful. Using the traditional method you are basically saying "no" - think about it... So all you are telling them is "no, NOT THAT!" It has the potential to create a lot of confusion. "If not that, then what should I do?" I imagine them saying. Yes, Clinton does give the animal a scratch and says "good boy" occasionally.
But is a scratch on the head a true reward? Is it enough to keep them wanting to do more?
When I tried clicker training for the first time it was miraculous to me. Things that I had tried and tried to train suddenly became very easy. For example, Snickers was very head shy when we got him. I had worked with him some to lower his head but the "reward" of letting go of the rope when he lowered his head didn't really entice him to want to do it. Older horses are always more difficult. So the first thing I did with the clicker was teach him to lower his head. It was wonderful! He wanted to do it more, and he followed me around after wanting more training!
Since then I have taught three foals all kinds of things, and worked with about ten other horses on various things that they have a problem with. My horse Bella, a mustang, is extremely head shy. I have worked diligently and extensively over the years to get her over this. It always takes weeks and lots of patience and in the end she tolerates it. Then, just when I think I've gotten her over it she explodes and I have to start over again. I still can't put the reins over her head. So I began using the clicker to get the reins over her head. In one 5 minute session she stopped throwing her head away from my hand (she can does this violently) and actually relaxed and let me bring the reins up to her ears. For the first time she lowered her head willingly and by herself while I lifted the reins near her ears. I will keep you posted on the progress of this. I also hope to use it to get her in the trailer...
Although it takes timing and patience just like traditional training does, using a clicker is generally a much easier to train. I also find it safer, calmer and the results come so much faster. The horse tends to remember the training, even if it was brief, because using this method activates the part of the brain called the "seeking circuit" which is a pleasure center. Certain types of activity activate this brain function and the memory of it stays there for a long time. It works similarly to the fear circuit, in which things that scare an animal stay in memory for a long time.
Using traditional training methods I would end up fighting with my horses, trying to be the tough one, showing them I was boss. I'm not saying I was good at it. I wasn't. I am good at clicker training and the results say it all. Snickers and Angel and actually all my horses have come so far in a short time without the rodeo. I don't feel bad for what I have to do, I enjoy it more. Now when I go out to the pasture to get a horse to train they all come running up to me, eager. I now train on a first come, first serve basis!
2 comments:
I click, too. I started out with my cat, and when I realized what I could do with an animal that most people think is untrainable (in fact, cats spend most of their time training us) I knew it would help with horses.
I started it with my horse, Mingo, but he became sick before I got far. It helped me so much during his illness with medical procedures--I was sold. He did things for me that hurt when he did them.
I lost Mingo, so when I got my new horse, Cole, it was clicker all the way. It has made everything so much easier! He is so enthusiastic, too!
Thanks for the comments, Judi! Sometimes I think that we horse clicker trainers are in the minority, but them I am pleasantly surprised at how many people are using it.
I tried it on my cat, too and wow, what a surprise! For the first time in her life she came when I called her name...
Would love to hear how you found out about it and some more of your experiences...
Post a Comment